These are representative questions, not a guaranteed request list. Assign an owner to each answer and keep the answer tied to the period-specific evidence.
Why did you select this CECL method for each portfolio? Be ready with the method-selection rationale, portfolio characteristics, available data, term and prepayment considerations, limitations, alternatives considered, and approval.
Why are the segments reasonable, and how do you know the segments still share similar risk? Show segment definitions, risk-characteristic analysis, migration or mix monitoring, portfolio changes, and the process for adding, splitting, merging, or retiring pools.
How do you know the data is complete and accurate? Walk through authoritative sources, extraction logic, reconciliations, field-level checks, exception resolution, period archiving, and independent review.
What historical period or proxy did you use, and why is it relevant? Explain the lookback, definitions, data limitations, mergers or system changes, external sources, and how historical information is distinguished from current-condition and forecast adjustments.
How did the forecast and reversion affect the estimate? Identify the forecast horizon, variables, scenarios, sources, reversion method, historical anchor, sensitivity, approval, and rationale for the selected approach.
What is driving the Q factors, and how did you avoid double-counting? Trace each factor to a documented condition, source, cause-and-effect relationship, direction, magnitude, period, owner, approval, and review of overlap with model inputs.
Why did the allowance move from the prior period? Use an attribution that separates volume, credit quality, charge offs, forecast, reversion, Q factors, segmentation, methodology, and data or system changes.
How did prior estimates compare with actual outcomes? Present backtesting or outcomes analysis at useful portfolio levels, explain material differences and timing effects, and show what management changed or why it retained the approach.
Who validated the process, and how was independence addressed? Describe the validator's role, expertise, reporting line, scope, timing, limitations, findings, management responses, and closure or monitoring.
What has changed since the last examination or audit? Use the change log to cover new products, portfolio composition, data sources, code, software releases, assumptions, forecasts, reversion, Q factors, vendors, findings, and control changes.
How does the booked allowance reconcile to the calculation and disclosures? Show the calculation-to-GL tie-out, provision entry, roll-forward, regulatory-report or financial-statement reconciliation, disclosure support, and review sign-offs.
Which third parties support the estimate, and how do you oversee them? Provide the third party inventory, due diligence, contract scope, assurance reports, customization and configuration, performance monitoring, findings, and contingency plan.