Using models to evaluate lending decisions
Loan-pricing models also provide objective measures to evaluate lending decisions. Modern systems commonly rely on several approaches. One method compares the loan with an alternative investment, asking whether the institution would earn more by making the loan or by leaving the funds in the investment portfolio. Another common approach is an income method that calculates expected returns, such as return on assets or return on equity.
Importantly, a loan-pricing model does not tell a lender exactly what rate to charge. Market conditions, competitive pressures, and customer or member relationships still influence the final pricing decision. The model provides a clearer view of the relative value and risk of different loans, helping institutions make better-informed lending decisions.
Reviewing and adjusting loan pricing
Loan pricing models should also make it easier for financial institutions to take into account changing environments and adjust rates as needed, something regulators have encouraged.
“Management should continuously evaluate and adjust rates in response to changes in costs, competitive factors, or risks of a particular product type,” according to James L. Adams, supervising examiner at the Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia.
In a newsletter for community banks, Adams cited the Fed's Commercial Bank Examination Manual, which says, “Periodic review allows rates to be adjusted in response to changes in costs, competitive factors, or risks of a particular type of extension of credit.”
Governance, documentation, and model discipline
Regulatory guidance, such as Federal Reserve SR 11-7 and the OCC’s Model Risk Management Handbook, emphasizes the need for model governance and performance monitoring. Loan pricing models in a loan origination system should include:
- Documented assumptions
- Defined profitability targets
- Clear override tracking
- Periodic review of pricing performance
Abrigo’s Loan Pricing has automation that supports defensible documentation and reporting for financial institutions with lean staffing.
Loan origination software and pricing integration
Other benefits of integrating loan pricing models into systems like Abrigo LOS are that institutions can:
- Automatically incorporate risk ratings and collateral inputs
- Compare multiple pricing scenarios
- Solve for a target interest rate or target profitability metric
- Track and archive priced loans
- Generate reporting filtered by borrower, risk rating, responsible officer, or date
Integration with core systems can also allow cost-of-funds assumptions to be updated regularly based on benchmark indices.
Risk-based loan pricing allows financial institutions to offer competitive pricing on the best loans across borrower groups while either rejecting or pricing at a premium the loans that pose the highest risks. Market conditions, competitive pressures, and customer or member relationships still influence the final pricing decision. But the model provides a clearer view of the relative value and risk of different loans, helping institutions make better-informed lending decisions.
Providing systematic loan pricing for new loan origination and for annual reviews helps financial institutions calculate a defensible and consistent price. Abrigo’s loan pricing software integrates with its loan origination software to transform pricing from a bottleneck to a quick exercise. Banks and credit unions can intelligently set prices based on risk and profitability targets, configuring the model to fit their pricing sophistication, from simple to complex as needed.
Editor's note: This blog was originally published in 2022 and has since been updated for current best practices and accuracy.